May 21, 2007
The Philadelphia Diesel Difference - Working Group Meeting
Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission (DVRPC)
190 North Independence Mall West,
8th Floor,
Philadelphia, PA 19106
IN ATTENDANCE:
Emily Bockian Landsburg, Energy Cooperative
& Philadelphia Fry-O-Diesel
Harry Boyd, Krapf Bus Co.
Francine Carlini, PADEP
Ed Carreras, Carreras Systems
Eric Cheung, Clean Air Council
Fred Cummings, City of Philadelphia Division
of Aviation
Mike Detwiler, Great Valley School District
Thomas Hole, Ransome Caterpillar
Thomas Huynh, City of Philadelphia, Air
Management Services
Sean Greene, DVRPC
Lisa MaGee, PRPA
Dan Snowden, PennDOT
Alison Tracy, City of Philadelphia, Air
Management Services
Barbara Wilson, Krapf Bus
MINUTES TAKEN BY:
Alison Tracy
INTRODUCTIONS AND ANNOUNCEMENTS:
Alison welcomed the group and announced
that the Air Quality Partnership's Ozone
Action Kickoff, coordinated by DVRPC,
went very well. Sean elaborated that 3
cameras covered the event and 25 coupons
for free E85 ethanol or B20 biodiesel
were given out. NBC's meteorologist "Hurricane"
Schwartz spoke at the event, and Eric
and Alison presented Lower Merion School
District with Platinum-Level recognition
on behalf of PDD.
The Funding Forum held at the end of April
by EPA Regions 1, 2 and 3 with MARAMA
and NESCAUM was successful. Eric and Alison
both participated on a panel discussing
funding options and Eric gave a presentation
on the NCDC Ports project. Presentations
from this event are available on MARAMA's
website.
The Mayor's Local Action Plan was unveiled
during Earth Week, and the Mayor issued
an Executive Order requiring use of alternative
fuels and anti-idling policies in construction
vehicles, and the reduction of fuel use
by OFM. The Mayor spoke last week at a
C40 Clinton Initiative event on Philly's
success with alternative fuels (biodiesel,
CNG, hybrids, etc.). Alison contributed
to the presentation.
AMS is in search of candidates to nominate
as possible members of the Air Pollution
Control Board. Please contact Alison if
you are aware of any individuals who might
be interested.
Alison asked the group whether anyone
had an objection to rescheduling the September
meeting to September 10th, as she will
be out the second half of the month.
A delegation from Sweden was in Philadelphia
recently and they made a presentation
describing their experiences in various
air quality projects including congestion
pricing and alternative fuels (e.g. methanol,
ethanol, biodiesel, methane).
Temple University is initiating a retrofit
project for 10 vehicles as part of a consent
decree with the city. Details are forthcoming.
The Udall Foundation is sponsoring a biodiesel
bus tour which is stopping in Philadelphia
on June 13 to promote the fuel. AMS has
been asked to participate in the event.
Realtime air quality information is now
available on the City's website at http://www.phila.gov/health/units/ams/index.html.
PHILADELPHIA DIESEL DIFFERENCE ACTIVITIES
UPDATE:
Because of the upcoming Clean School Bus
USA grant which is expected to open soon,
PDD is switching its focus to recruiting
school districts.
The Clean Air 5K last month was successful
and featured a Platinum recognition to
Great Valley School District for their
work in implementing clean diesel technology.
Other recent events where PDD material
was passed out included: Temple Ambler's
Earth Fest, the City's Sustainability
Fair and the Spruce Hill May Fair.
Eric noted that he has been in contact
with a representative from a group called
the Clean Air Task Force which is a nonprofit
that seeks opportunities for implementing
diesel retrofit projects. They are working
with GASP, a group in Pittsburgh that
is retrofitting fleet vehicles with particulate
filters using grant money from the Heinz
Foundation.
CAC, EPA, AMS and the University of Pennsylvania
are working on a draft agenda for a diesel
health effects symposium to be held in
Fall or Spring. A one-pager on the event
is being compiled to clarify the purpose
of the event to prospective participants.
Alison, Eric and Bill will soon be contacting
individuals to invite them to participate
on a Steering Committee for the event.
COMMITTEE UPDATES:
Again, Lower Merion and Great Valley School
Districts have now received Platinum-level
recognition. Next on the list is Packer
terminal. Eric will attempt to complete
this before the press conference to publicize
the project. This was postponed after
a snowstorm in February, and has yet to
be rescheduled.
GRANT UPDATES:
The state of Pennsylvania's Alternative
Fuels Incentive Grant is open until mid-June.
It is also expected that EPA will open
its Clean School Bus USA grant soon. SEPTA
is applying for funds from the Department
of Transportation for hybrid bus technology
and has asked CAC for a letter of support.
ONE MINUTE UPDATES:
DVRPC will be deciding sometime in mid-June
whether to make competitive CMAQ funds
available for the coming fiscal year.
Sean will keep PDD posted. The announcement
would go out in July.
The Delaware River channel deepening project
is moving forward. A $300 million bond
will include funds for 2 electric gantry
cranes. Eventually, diesel powered cranes
will be phased out.
The state's Environmental Quality Board
has approved draft anti-idling legislation
and PennDOT is working to ensure compliance
with that rule if it is passed into law.
PennDOT's Construction and Materials section
is still reviewing the City's draft contract
language and will then meet with counsel
to discuss.
Krapf is working on a contract for 60
school bus retrofit in Westchester County.
Emily is working with Krapf on an AFIG
grant for 5 districts to use 1.1 million
gallons per year of biodiesel.
WEEKLY PRESENTATION:
Emily gave a presentation on the benefits
of biodiesel. Locally, several fleets
use biodiesel including Great Valley School
District, the Philadelphia Zoo, and the
Philadelphia Eagles. Biodiesel is a diesel-compatible
fuel processed from vegetable oils such
as soy. It has low sulfate content, emits
little particulate matter, and is non-toxic.
AFIG grants are available from the state
to defray additional costs over regular
diesel. Although some Original Equipment
Manufacturers have said they will not
extend their warranties to cover the use
of biodiesel, the fuel is widely considered
safe for use so long as the fuel meets
ASTM specifications. There are also some
mechanical benefits to using biodiesel,
such as its high lubricity and solvent
characteristics which help to maintain
and even improve engine performance. There
are some concerns with biodiesel including
the fact that tests on the NOx effect
of the fuel are inconclusive-that is,
NOx may decrease or increase using biodiesel
depending on the engine type, duty cycle
and other factors. Emily stressed the
importance of local feedstocks in minimizing
life cycle emissions from biofuels. The
representatives from Great Valley noted
that they have had no mechanical problems
since transitioning to the fuel, and will
continue to lobby other school districts
to implement the technology.
NEXT MEETING AND LOCATION:
The next meeting will be held June 17th,
2007 at DVRPC.